New Study: Comic Books Particularly Important in Encouraging Boys to Read

My nearly-seven-year-old boy likes الـ 99, but they're difficult to find in Arabic in Cairo. Much harder to find than a Mickey!

I have Arabic comic books  on the brain. And then this morning I saw this, from the Vancouver Sun:

Teachers and school boards should embrace comic books and graphic novels as a “gateway” literature, helping children transition towards more complex narratives and helping boys catch up with girls in reading achievement, according to a new study.

I don’t know about categorizing graphic novels as “gateway” literature; I think good ones can be an end in and of themselves. But, in any case, the Canadian study—released Wednesday—noted that comics and graphic novels “can help bridge the learning gap between boys and girls.”

I wasn’t too worried about Arabic-reading boys falling behind Arabic-reading girls—although perhaps I’m wrong in that—but I am happy that the study refutes the idea that kids who read comics don’t or won’t read other materials. “The research shows that boys who read comics also read more text-based material and report more reading enjoyment than boys who don’t read comics….”

And yes, there is something very appealing about comics, even the ones not written so well. My son’s Arabic teacher sent home Goha-themed comics last year; you’ve never seen him devour the assigned Arabic texts like he wanted to read and explore that comic.

The end of the Sun article gets into how we define reading. The head of a boys-only school in Ottawa asserts that reading online is reading (isn’t it?), in which case Egyptians do a lot more reading than is generally reported. But in what ways does reading online help us “follow a sequence of events, interpret symbols, predict what will happen next and connect narratives to [our] own experiences”—key skills in reading and life?

Well, probably not as much as a good comic.

Advertisements
This entry was posted in boys and reading, graphic novels, how to encourage reading, reluctant readers and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to New Study: Comic Books Particularly Important in Encouraging Boys to Read

  1. saara says:

    Comics, like graphic novels, are good for encouraging not just boys to read, but those less inclined to reading (reluctant readers).

    As for reading online helping to develop reading skills, it all depends on what’s being read. Some blogs provide great content. But for youngsters I don’t know how much they’re interested in reading as opposted to chatting and playing games 🙂

    • mlynxqualey says:

      Saara,

      Yes, although I suppose it tends to be boys who are more likely to be reluctant readers.

      And it certainly depends on the website. When my elder was learning to read English, he enjoyed Starfall.Com, which is a reading website with a few reading games. Perhaps if I let him completely alone on the computer, he would’ve played games, but I prefer directed computer time, certainly for younger ones.

      Anyhow, I don’t think anything equivalent exists in Arabic. There are games, there are even a few “educational” games, but nothing to help a child learn to read.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s